Where Are the Worst Drivers in New York State?

New York City residents might have a reputation for being aggressive drivers, but is that reputation deserved? The data reveals that when compared to other counties in the state, New York City is far from the worst. In fact, based on the number of accidents per 1,000 residents, the five boroughs of NYC come in almost last.

So where are the worst drivers in the Empire State? That’s a subjective question and a lot of criteria could be used to qualify “worst.” Rosenblum Law looked at newly-released 2017 auto accident data, including data on death and serious injury to determine which areas have the “worst drivers.” While accidents are not always the result of poor driving habits, the majority of crashes–77%–had human factors. Here’s what was uncovered.

NY Counties with the Most Car Crashes

The counties with the greatest number of accidents corresponds closely with the list of counties with the greatest population as well as those with the most vehicle miles traveled (VMT). Long Island’s Suffolk and Nassau Counties had the most accidents in 2017. Queens and Brooklyn came in third and fourth, respectively, followed by Erie County on the Canadian border.

However, when ranked by crashes per 1,000 VMT, the picture changes. Brooklyn, which has the seventh-most vehicle miles traveled with nearly 14 million, had highest rate of automotive accidents: 1.75 per 1,000 VMT. Yates County, with the third-least vehicle miles traveled, came in at No. 9 on this list. Long Island’s Nassau County, which had the second-most accidents in 2017 also had the second-most vehicle miles traveled and still came in at No. 6 for accidents per 1,000 miles.

NY CountyRoad Rage Crashes 2017Road Rage Crashes Per 1,000 VMT
Manhattan1640.0185
Bronx 1570.017
Brooklyn2130.0159
Queens 2170.0107
Niagara 240.0059
Schenectady 180.0057
Erie 1170.0055
Staten Island300.0051
Fulton 60.0049
Albany 430.0047

NY Counties with the Most Serious Accidents

Not all accidents are equal; we also sorted counties based on crashes that resulted in death and serious injury. The good news is that the average fatality rate is only 0.38% across all counties, and no county had a fatality rate of higher than 1.5%.

Orleans County, northeast of Erie and next door to Niagara County, had the highest lethal crash rate with 1.37% of crashes resulting in death. Genesee County, just south of Orleans, came in at No. 6 on this list.

NY CountySpeed-Related Crashes 2017Speed Crashes Per 1,000 People
Franklin 2580.2155
Allegany 2150.1833
Cortland 2700.1743
Essex 2680.163
Delaware 2490.158
Schoharie 1440.1567
Hamilton 470.1567
Sullivan 3910.1564
Orleans 1140.1492
Otsego 2410.1438

When one includes serious injuries in the data, the picture changes again, but not dramatically. Orleans, Schuyler, Lewis and Fulton Counties all rank high on the list of counties with the highest rate of serious injury and death in auto accidents. Niagara County, which does not appear on any other list, pops up here with the eighth-highest serious injury and death rate. However, Genesee County falls off the top-10 list dropping all the way to No. 15.

However, when considering the rate of serious injury or death per 1,000 vehicle miles traveled, three of the five boroughs of New York City once again come out on top. Orleans County, which has ranked on nearly all the lists so far, had the highest rate of injury and death per VMT.

NY CountyAlcohol-Related Crashes 2017Alcohol-Related Crashes Per 1,000 People
Yates 250.0441
Orleans 310.0406
Niagara 1600.0395
Brooklyn5170.0386
Schuyler 190.0379
Cortland 510.0329
Cayuga 660.0325
Allegany 380.0324
Oswego 980.0323
Bronx 2930.0318

So Which County is Truly the Worst?

There’s no definitive winner. Orleans, Niagara, and Tompkins counties all seem to have dangerous drivers. Brooklyn and the Bronx don’t fare well either. Ultimately it will depend on what criteria one wishes to use. To that end, the following charts show the NY counties with the most drunk driving accidents, road rage-related accidents, and accidents in which speed is a factor per vehicle miles traveled. As to which county is truly the worst, we’ll let the drivers decide that.

Road Rage Crashes

StateTexting FinePointsRankStatute 
Alabama25236AL § 32-5A-350
Alaska50025AK § 28.35.161
Arizona150218AZ HB2318
Arkansas100329AR Code § 27-51-1607 (2012)
California20--45CA 12-1-23123.5
Colorado30047Section 42-4-239, C.R.S.
Connecticut125222CT Gen Stat § 14-296aa (2013)
Delaware50--412 DE Code § 4176C
Florida30325FL -316-305
Georgia150133GA § 40-6-241.2
Hawaii250--30HI Rev Stat § 291C-137 (2014)
Idaho85--41ID SECTION 49-1401A
Illinois75103IL Sec. 12-610.2.
Indiana500--10IN § 9-21-8-59
Iowa30--43Iowa Code 321.276
Kansas60--20KS 8-15-111
Kentucky25326KY Rev Stat § 189.292 (2012)
Louisiana500--9LA Rev Stat § 32:300.5
Maine25021529-A MRS §2119
Maryland70135MD CODE§ 21–1124.1
Massachusetts100238MA 90 - 8M
Michigan100221MI CODE Section 257.602b
Minnesota225--32MN 169.475
Mississippi100--39MS § 63-33-1
Missouri200213V.A.M.S. 304.820
Montana0--46--
Nebraska200312NE Revised Statute 60-6,179.01
Nevada50--40NRS 484B.165
New Hampshire100--39NH Section 265:105-a
New Jersey400319NJ Rev Stat § 39:4-97.3 (2013)
New Mexico25--43NM Stat § 66-7-374 (2014)
New York20056NY Veh & Traf L § 1225-C (2014)
North Carolina100227NC § 20-137.4A.
North Dakota10068ND Code 39-08-23
Ohio150411OH 4511.204
Oklahoma100--3947 OK Stat § 47-11-901d (2015)
Oregon1000--1O.R.S. § 811.507
Pennsylvania5032375 Pa.C.S.A. § 3316
Rhode Island85--16RI Gen L § 31-22-30 (2012)
South Carolina25--44SC SECTION 56-5-3890
South Dakota100231SD § 32-26-47
Tennessee50--42T. C. A. § 55-8-199
Texas99228TX Sec. 545.4251
Utah75052UT Code § 41-6a-1716(2)
Vermont100--3423 V.S.A. § 1099
Virginia125324VA § 46.2-1078.1
Washington136--14RCW 46.61.672
West Virginia100--37WV §17C-14-15
Wisconsin40044WI ST 346.89
Wyoming75--17WY Stat § 31-5-237

Speed-Related Crashes

StateTexting FinePointsRank
Alabama$25236
Alaska$50025
Arizona$150218
Arkansas$100329
California$20--45
Colorado$30047
Connecticut$125222
Delaware$50--41
Florida$30325
Georgia$150133
Hawaii$250--30
Idaho$85--41
Illinois$75103
Indiana$500--10
Iowa$30--43
Kansas$60--20
Kentucky$25326
Louisiana$500--9
Maine$250215
Maryland$70135
Massachusetts$100238
Michigan$100221
Minnesota$225--32
Mississippi$100--39
Missouri$200213
Montana$0--46
Nebraska$200312
Nevada$50--40
New Hampshire$100--39
New Jersey$400319
New Mexico$25--43
New York$20056
North Carolina$100227
North Dakota$10068
Ohio$150411
Oklahoma$100--39
Oregon$1,000--1
Pennsylvania$50323
Rhode Island$85--16
South Carolina$25--44
South Dakota$100231
Tennessee$50--42
Texas$99228
Utah$75052
Vermont$100--34
Virginia$125324
Washington$136--14
West Virginia$100--37
Wisconsin$40044
Wyoming$75--17

Alcohol-Related Crashes

[table “20” not found /]