A ticket for not moving over can catch you off guard, especially if you thought you gave the stopped car enough room. It's normal to wonder what it will cost and whether it's worth fighting.
This page explains what New York's Move Over Law requires, what a guilty plea can cost, and what courts look at in these cases. Before you plead guilty or pay the ticket, talk to a lawyer about your options.
What does New York's Move Over Law require?
New York's Move Over Law (VTL 1144-a) requires you to use "due care" to avoid hitting certain vehicles that are parked, stopped, or standing on the shoulder or any portion of the highway. The statute does not define "due care." In People v. Krahforst, the court explained that it means using the care a reasonably prudent driver would exercise under the circumstances. The law first took effect on January 1, 2011, and has been expanded several times since.
The law covers four groups of vehicles:
- Emergency vehicles. Police cars, fire trucks, ambulances, and other authorized emergency vehicles displaying the required red, red-and-white, or specified blue light combinations.
- Hazard vehicles. Vehicles displaying amber lights, such as highway maintenance and construction vehicles. Tow trucks designed to tow or push disabled vehicles may also display blue or blue-and-amber lights, but the required amber lights must also be displayed. Vehicles owned and operated by New York State or a county, city, town, or village and designed for ice and snow removal may display one or more amber lights, one or more green lights, or combination green-and-amber lights. However, when these vehicles are engaged in a hazardous operation, they must also display amber lights if they are displaying green lights.
- Vehicles with blue or green lights. These include vehicles authorized to display blue lights for volunteer firefighters and green lights for members of volunteer ambulance services or certain mobile crisis teams. The lights must be authorized and displayed under the conditions set by law.
- Any other motor vehicle. Since March 27, 2024, the law also covers any motor vehicle parked, stopped, or standing on the shoulder or any portion of a parkway or controlled-access highway, like a car with a flat tire. No special lights are required.
On parkways and controlled-access highways (roads where access is limited to designated entrances and exits), due care includes moving out of the lane containing or immediately next to the shoulder where the covered vehicle is stopped. That lane change must still follow the other traffic laws, including the rules on obeying signs and lane markings (VTL 1110) and making safe lane changes (VTL 1128). If a lane change is unsafe or unlawful, the driver must still exercise due care to avoid a collision. The New York State Thruway Authority also notes that the law applies to vehicles stopped on either side of the road, not just the right shoulder.
In short, the law asks drivers to give stopped vehicles space. State agencies recommend slowing down and moving over when it is safe. The statute itself requires drivers to exercise due care and, on parkways and controlled-access highways, to move out of the specified lane when that movement is lawful.
Penalties for a move over ticket
A ticket is an accusation, not a conviction. You are presumed innocent, and the state has to prove its case. But if you plead guilty or are found guilty, these penalties apply. The fine and jail limits come from the general penalty law for traffic infractions (VTL 1800):
| Penalty | First violation | Second violation (both violations committed within 18 months) | Third or subsequent violation (all counted violations committed within 18 months) |
| Fine | Up to $150 | Up to $300 | Up to $450 |
| Possible jail | Up to 15 days | Up to 45 days | Up to 90 days |
| DMV points per conviction | 2 | 2 | 2 |
| State surcharge | $88, or $93 in a town or village court | $88, or $93 in a town or village court | $88, or $93 in a town or village court |
These are the general maximum penalties for VTL 1144-a violations because the law does not set a separate fine schedule for this violation. The state surcharge is an extra fee added on top of the fine. Under the law, the court can order a fine, jail, or both.
The points can also lead to more costs:
- Driver Responsibility Assessment. If you get 6 or more points in 18 months, the DMV charges a Driver Responsibility Assessment of $100 a year for three years, plus $25 a year for each point over 6.
- License suspension or revocation review. If you accumulate 11 or more points within 24 months, the DMV may require you to attend a formal hearing to investigate habitual or persistent traffic violations. This threshold does not apply when all the points result from a single alcohol- or drug-related driving conviction or incident. A hearing may also be required if you accumulate 9 or more points from speeding violations within 24 months, or 4 or more additional points within 12 months after attending a formal hearing. Even if you have not reached those point totals, the DMV may require a hearing if you are charged with 3 or more point-assessed violations within an unusually short period. Suspension or revocation action may follow a hearing; reaching a point threshold does not automatically suspend your license.
- Extra tickets from the same stop. Each additional ticket may bring its own fine and points if you are convicted. Our page on New York traffic ticket points explains how they add up.
These are separate DMV rules: the Driver Responsibility Assessment uses an 18-month period, while the point-based hearing and possible suspension or revocation review uses a 24-month period.
Two points may sound small, but they count toward these totals. That's why it's worth knowing your options first.
Don't plead guilty before you talk to a lawyer. Call 888-883-5529 for a free consultation.

Let's Talk About Your Traffic Ticket
Call Us - We've Handled Over 100,000 Traffic Violations
Quick, free, and no obligation.
Is failing to move over the same as failing to yield?
No. These are two different laws, and the ticket number matters. The Move Over Law (VTL 1144-a) is about vehicles that are already stopped. A separate law (VTL 1144) covers an authorized emergency vehicle that is immediately approaching while sounding an audible signal and displaying the required red light, subject to statutory exceptions for certain police vehicles and bicycles.
| Move Over Law (VTL 1144-a) | Failure to yield to an emergency vehicle (VTL 1144) | |
| The other vehicle is | Parked, stopped, or standing | Immediately approaching while sounding an audible signal and displaying the required warning light, subject to statutory exceptions |
| What you must do | Use due care, and on parkways and controlled-access highways, move out of the lane containing or immediately next to the shoulder when the move is legal and safe | Pull over as close as possible to the right edge of the road (or either edge of a one-way road) and stop until the emergency vehicle passes |
| Fine for a first violation | Up to $150 | Up to $275 |
| DMV points | 2 | 3 |
If your ticket says VTL 1144 instead of 1144-a, our page on failure to yield to an emergency vehicle in New York covers that charge. Check the section number on your ticket before you decide what to do.
Defenses to a move over ticket
You can fight a move over ticket. Maybe you know you didn't change lanes. That doesn't mean you have to accept every point and penalty on the ticket. The law asks for due care, and whether you used it depends on the facts.
One court decision shows how judges look at these cases. In People v. Krahforst, 54 Misc. 3d 1010 (Cohoes City Ct. 2016), a driver in the right lane of I-787 didn't move over for two police cars stopped at the side of the road. She said a truck blocked her view and a car she saw in her mirror made a lane change unsafe. The court ruled that the test is objective: whether a reasonably prudent driver would have considered it safe to change lanes. It found that a lane change was safe under the circumstances and found her guilty. This means a lawyer can focus on the real conditions you faced, not just what you felt in the moment.
Here are some things a lawyer can look at:
- Whether a lane change was safe and legal. The law requires a lane change only when it can be made in compliance with the other traffic laws. Heavy traffic, a car in your blind spot, or lane markings that prohibit crossing can all matter.
- Whether you had enough time and could see the vehicle. Distance, speed, curves, and weather can affect how much warning you had.
- Whether the road was covered. For an ordinary car on the shoulder, the law applies only on parkways and controlled-access highways. For emergency and hazard vehicles, the type of vehicle and the lights it was displaying matter.
- Whether you used due care in other ways. On roads where the statute does not specifically require a lane change, the general duty to exercise due care still applies. A lawyer can look at whether you slowed down, changed lanes when appropriate, or took other reasonable steps to avoid a collision.
- Whether a deal to plead to a lesser charge is possible. Many courts outside New York City allow this, depending on the facts and the prosecutor.
A ticket can also matter outside traffic court. In Despian v. Garcia, 2013 NY Slip Op 30520(U) (Sup. Ct., N.Y. County 2013), a New York City detective riding as a passenger in an unmarked police car sued after a three-car crash involving a Honda minivan and two police cars.
In that lawsuit, the court discussed whether the minivan driver had taken the actions required by VTL 1144 after hearing the siren and seeing the lights of an approaching emergency vehicle. That case involved the failure-to-yield law, not the Move Over Law, but it shows that how you drove around emergency vehicles can come up in a civil lawsuit, not just in traffic court.
Every case is different, and a defense that worked in one case may not work in another. Before you plead guilty, find out what options you have in your court.
Special situations to know about
Some drivers face extra consequences from a move over ticket. These are the situations to check:
- You have a junior license or permit. Under New York law (VTL 510-c), a class DJ or MJ learner's permit or driver's license must be suspended for 60 days after a conviction or finding for one "serious traffic violation." That list includes violations of Article 26 of the Vehicle and Traffic Law, which is where the Move Over Law sits. Our page on junior license traffic tickets explains these rules.
- You got the ticket in New York City. Most non-criminal traffic tickets issued in the five boroughs go to the DMV's Traffic Violations Bureau (TVB), which doesn't allow plea bargaining. There, you either plead guilty or plead not guilty and have a hearing.
- You have an out-of-state license. New York can suspend your privilege to drive in New York. The DMV tells out-of-state drivers to contact their own state's motor vehicle agency about how a New York conviction affects them.
- You got more than one ticket. Officers can write separate tickets for other charges from the same stop, such as speeding or an unsafe lane change. Each conviction adds its own points.
If any of these apply to you, the stakes are higher. It's worth getting advice about your specific situation before your court date.

What to do after a move over ticket
The first few days after a ticket matter more than most people think. Details about traffic, timing, and visibility fade quickly, and pleading guilty too soon can close off options you didn’t know you had. These steps can help protect your options while you decide what to do:
- Don't plead guilty or pay yet. A conviction brings 2 points, a fine, and a state surcharge.
- Check the section number. Make sure the ticket says VTL 1144-a and note any other tickets from the same stop.
- Note your court date. Write it down and plan for it, because missing court can cause new problems.
- Write down what happened. Include the road, the lane you were in, traffic around you, the weather, and when you first saw the stopped vehicle.
- Save any proof. Keep dashcam video, photos of the area, and the names of any passengers who saw what happened.
- Call for a free consultation. We can go over your ticket and your driving record with you.
None of these steps commit you to fighting the ticket. They help make sure you have the facts and the time to make an informed choice. If you have questions about your ticket or your driving record, a free consultation can be an excellent place to get answers before your court date.
FAQs
Is a move over ticket a crime in New York?
No. It's a traffic infraction, and New York law (VTL 155) says a traffic infraction is not a crime. A conviction still adds points and costs money, so it's worth taking seriously.
Does the Move Over Law apply on local roads?
Partly. The duty to use due care around stopped emergency vehicles, hazard vehicles, and vehicles displaying authorized blue or green lights applies on any public road. The specific lane-change rule, and the rule for ordinary stopped cars, apply on parkways and controlled-access highways.
Can a defensive driving course take the points off?
Not exactly. The DMV says its crash prevention course can reduce up to four points when it calculates your total for a possible suspension, and may lower your insurance premiums by up to 10 percent. It doesn't erase the conviction or reduce a Driver Responsibility Assessment.
What happens if I ignore a move over ticket from New York City?
The DMV says that if you don't answer a Traffic Violations Bureau ticket on time, your driver license will be suspended. Answering on time, even with a not guilty plea, avoids a suspension for failing to answer.
Talk to a Rosenblum traffic attorney
I know a move over ticket can be frustrating, especially if you thought you were driving carefully. But a ticket is not a conviction. Whether you broke the law depends on the conditions you faced, like traffic, visibility, and whether a lane change was safe.
You have the right to make the state prove its case. Before you pay the ticket or plead guilty, understand your options. Rosenblum Law has handled over 100,000 traffic tickets.
Call 888-883-5529 for a free, no-obligation consultation.
Sources
- NY Senate, VTL 1144-a (Move Over Law)
- NY Senate, VTL 1144 (yielding to approaching emergency vehicles)
- NY Senate, VTL 1800 (penalties for traffic infractions)
- NY Senate, VTL 1128 (driving on roadways laned for traffic)
- NY Senate, VTL 109 (controlled-access highway)
- NY Senate, VTL 155 (traffic infraction)
- NY Senate, VTL 375 (authorized vehicle lights)
- NY Senate, VTL 510-c (junior permits and licenses)
- NY Senate, VTL 1809 and VTL 1809-e (surcharges)
- NY Senate, Article 26, Right of Way
- NY DMV, Memo on Chapter 517 of the Laws of 2023 (March 12, 2024) (expanded Move Over Law, effective March 27, 2024)
- NY DMV, Memo on Chapter 387 of the Laws of 2010 (original Move Over Law, effective January 1, 2011)
- NY DMV, Memo on Chapter 504 of the Laws of 2022 (November 1, 2022) (green lights on snow-removal vehicles and the requirement to display amber lights during hazardous operations)
- NY DMV, Memo on Chapter 71 of the Laws of 2024 (green lights for mobile crisis team members, effective June 5, 2024)
- NY DMV, Move Over Law reminder and ticket data (October 15, 2026)
- NY DMV, Driver Responsibility Assessment
- NY DMV, Chapter 2: How to Keep Your License (point system, crash prevention course)
- NY DMV, Plead To or Pay NYC 'TVB' Traffic Tickets
- NY DMV, Tickets Received in Another State
- NY DMV, 2026 Point System Memorandum (2026 point changes and 24-month administrative review period)
- New York State, 15 NYCRR 131.4, DMV regulations (administrative action and formal hearing thresholds)
- NY State Thruway Authority, Move Over Law
- People v. Krahforst, 54 Misc. 3d 1010, 2016 NY Slip Op 26444 (Cohoes City Ct. 2016)
- Despian v. Garcia, 2013 NY Slip Op 30520(U) (Sup. Ct., N.Y. County, Mar. 14, 2013)

